Skip to main content
WUHLD
← Back to glossary

Pre-emption Rights

Also known as: Right of First Refusal, First Refusal Rights

Definition

Pre-emption rights are legal provisions giving existing shareholders the first opportunity to purchase new or existing shares in a company before they can be offered to outsiders, protecting shareholders from dilution and unwanted third-party involvement.

Understanding pre-emption rights is essential for business owners creating wills, as these provisions can determine whether your shares pass to your chosen beneficiaries or must be sold to co-shareholders first.

What Do Pre-emption Rights Mean?

Pre-emption rights have two legal sources: statutory and contractual. Under the Companies Act 2006, Section 561, companies must offer newly issued shares to existing shareholders first—this applies only to new share allotments, not transfers of existing shares. Companies commonly include contractual pre-emption rights in their articles of association or shareholders' agreements covering share transfers, giving co-shareholders first opportunity to purchase when a shareholder sells, retires, or dies.

When triggered by death, retirement, or other events, the process works like this: the selling shareholder or executor notifies existing shareholders of the transfer, stating price and deadline (typically 14-28 days). Shareholders can accept pro-rata to their holdings or decline. If accepted, shares transfer at the price set by the articles' valuation mechanism. If declined, shares pass to the intended beneficiary. Emma owned 50% of a company worth £1.2 million when she died. Her shareholders' agreement required offering shares to her partner first at fair value (£600,000). The partner declined, so Emma's shares transferred to her children's trust, preserving the family stake.

Pre-emption rights significantly affect estate planning. When you die, these provisions may require offering shares to existing shareholders before they pass to your will beneficiaries—your family might receive cash instead of business ownership. However, "permitted transfers" clauses can allow direct transfer to family members without triggering pre-emption rights. The tax implications are substantial: binding obligations to sell on death may cause HMRC to deny Business Property Relief (100% Inheritance Tax relief), arguing you owned sale proceeds rather than business property. Cross-option agreements preserve relief by creating options rather than obligations. David owned 40% of a business worth £320,000 with binding pre-emption rights. HMRC denied Business Property Relief, creating a £128,000 tax liability that could have been avoided.

Common Questions

"How do pre-emption rights affect what happens to my shares when I die?" When you die, pre-emption rights may require your executor to offer your shares to existing shareholders before they pass to will beneficiaries. Your intended beneficiaries might receive sale proceeds rather than the shares themselves, depending on whether existing shareholders purchase them.

"Can I leave my company shares to my children if there are pre-emption rights?" It depends on your company's articles and shareholders' agreement. Some include "permitted transfers" allowing shares to pass directly to family members. Others require offering shares to existing shareholders first, regardless of beneficiary. Check your company documents to understand what applies.

"Do pre-emption rights affect Business Property Relief on my shares?" Yes, significantly. If your articles create a binding obligation to sell shares on death, HMRC may deny Business Property Relief because you effectively own sale proceeds rather than business property. Cross-option agreements can preserve relief by creating options rather than obligations.

Common Misconceptions

Myth: Pre-emption rights mean I can't leave my company shares to whoever I want in my will.

Reality: Pre-emption rights don't prevent naming beneficiaries in your will, but may require offering shares to existing shareholders first. If shareholders decline, shares pass to your chosen beneficiaries. "Permitted transfers" clauses can allow direct transfer to family without triggering pre-emption rights.

Myth: Pre-emption rights and "right of first refusal" are exactly the same thing.

Reality: While often used interchangeably, they can differ. "Right of first refusal" means shareholders match third-party terms already agreed. "Right of first offer" means offering shares to shareholders before any third-party negotiations. Both are pre-emption types with different processes.

  • Articles of Association: The constitutional document where pre-emption rights are typically embedded, specifying when they apply and valuation mechanisms.
  • Shareholders' Agreement: A contractual supplement often containing additional pre-emption provisions, including permitted transfers and valuation methods.
  • Company Shares: The assets subject to pre-emption rights—understanding share ownership is essential to how pre-emption operates.
  • Drag-Along Rights: A complementary mechanism allowing majority shareholders to force minority shareholders to join sales.
  • Tag-Along Rights: Mirror protection allowing minority shareholders to join majority sales, working alongside pre-emption rights.

Need Help with Your Will?

If you own company shares, understanding how pre-emption rights affect your estate plan is essential for ensuring your business passes according to your wishes and preserving valuable tax reliefs.

Create your will with confidence using WUHLD's guided platform. For just £99.99, you'll get your complete, legally binding will plus three expert guides. Preview your will free before paying anything—no credit card required.

Legal Disclaimer:

This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. WUHLD is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Laws and guidance change and their application depends on your circumstances. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified solicitor or regulated professional. Unless stated otherwise, information relates to England and Wales.